Back to Case Studies

$45K Judgment Settled for $18K in 90 Days

Small business owner negotiated 60% settlement through strategic documentation and lump-sum offer timing.

Financial charts and documents showing settlement analysis

Results at a Glance

Original Judgment

$45,000

Final Settlement

$18,000

Savings

$27,000 (60%)

Resolution Time

90 days

Payment Terms

Lump Sum

Credit Impact

Satisfied

The Situation

Maria owned a small retail business that struggled during the pandemic. A commercial lease dispute resulted in a $45,000 judgment against her personally. With the business recovering but cash flow still tight, she faced the threat of wage garnishment and bank levies.

The Challenge

Maria needed to resolve the judgment quickly to protect her business accounts and personal finances. However, she couldn't afford the full $45,000. She had approximately $20,000 available through a combination of savings and a small business line of credit.

The Strategy

Working with our settlement framework, Maria developed a three-part approach:

  • Documentation: Compiled comprehensive financial statements showing business recovery trajectory and personal financial constraints
  • Timing: Identified that the creditor was a property management company likely motivated by quick resolution over prolonged collection
  • Offer Structure: Proposed a lump-sum payment of $18,000 (40% of judgment) payable within 10 days of acceptance

The Negotiation

Maria's initial offer was $15,000 (33%). The creditor countered at $28,000 (62%). Through three rounds of negotiation over two weeks, they agreed on $18,000 with these key terms:

  • Payment within 10 days of signed agreement
  • Judgment satisfied in full upon payment
  • No admission of additional liability
  • Creditor to file satisfaction of judgment within 30 days

The Outcome

Maria paid $18,000 on day 8. The creditor filed the satisfaction of judgment on day 22. Total resolution time: 90 days from initial contact to judgment satisfaction filed.

Before & After

Before

  • $45,000 judgment with 10% annual interest accruing
  • Threat of wage garnishment (25% of disposable income)
  • Risk of business bank account levy
  • Judgment appearing on credit reports
  • Ongoing stress affecting business operations

After

  • $18,000 one-time payment (60% savings)
  • No garnishment or levy actions
  • Business accounts protected
  • Judgment marked "Satisfied" on credit reports
  • Peace of mind to focus on business growth

Resolution Timeline

Day 1

Initial contact with creditor attorney

Day 7

Submitted financial documentation and initial offer ($15K)

Day 14

Received counteroffer ($28K)

Day 21

Second round negotiation ($18K)

Day 28

Settlement agreement signed

Day 36

Payment sent ($18,000)

Day 90

Satisfaction of judgment filed

Key Takeaways

  • Lump-sum offers carry significant negotiating power
  • Comprehensive financial documentation strengthens your position
  • Understanding creditor motivations helps structure offers
  • Quick payment timelines can justify larger discounts
  • Written settlement agreements must include satisfaction terms

Ready to achieve similar results?

Use our proven tools and templates to resolve your judgment effectively.